Buffalo’s neighborhoods conjure up too many stereotypes to count. You’ve got hipster areas, preppy places, neighborhoods where college kids thrive, and of course, ghettos.
It seems as if there’s a neighborhood for everyone in Buffalo.
And while the city consistently ranks as one of the best places to live in New York thanks in part to tons of entertainment and jobs, it’s not all rainbows and sunshine in Buffalo. Some neighborhoods aren’t as safe as others.
So the question arises, which Buffalo neighborhoods are the most dangerous and which are the safest?
Today, we’ll use Saturday Night Science to determine which Buffalo hoods need a little tender loving care – the sore thumbs of the Buffalo area if you will. Realistically, you can’t expect all the neighborhoods to be amazing, although South Abbott ranks way above the rest.
We examined 50 of Buffalo’s neighborhoods to find out the most dangerous places to live. These places don’t quite measure up to Buffalo’s reputation.
Table Of Contents: Top 10 | Methodology | Summary | Table
So what’s the worst neighborhood to live in Buffalo for 2024? According to the most recent census data, Emerson looks to be the worst neighborhood in Buffalo.
Read on to see how we determined the places around Buffalo that need a pick-me-up. And remember, don’t blame the messenger.
For more New York reading, check out:
- Best Places To Live In New York
- Cheapest Places To Live In New York
- Most Dangerous Places In New York
The 10 Most Dangerous Neighborhoods In Buffalo For 2024
/10
Population: 2,108
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 3,128
Property Crime Per 100k: 5,057
Median Home Value: $50,600 (6th worst)
Median Income: $23,804 (worst)
More on Emerson: Data
/10
Population: 8,749
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 2,132
Property Crime Per 100k: 4,263
Median Home Value: $39,727 (2nd worst)
Median Income: $23,868 (2nd worst)
More on Broadway-Fillmore: Data
/10
Population: 3,029
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 1,201
Property Crime Per 100k: 3,448
Median Home Value: $47,550 (5th worst)
Median Income: $24,532 (4th worst)
More on Babcock: Data
/10
Population: 462
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 1,629
Property Crime Per 100k: 4,929
Median Home Value: $75,600 (2worst)
Median Income: $28,346 (9th worst)
More on Squaw Island: Data
/10
Population: 2,102
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 2,058
Property Crime Per 100k: 5,524
Median Home Value: $31,100 (worst)
Median Income: $32,992 (16th worst)
More on Medical Park: Data
/10
Population: 3,764
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 1,952
Property Crime Per 100k: 3,298
Median Home Value: $40,050 (3rd worst)
Median Income: $27,957 (8th worst)
More on Genesee Moselle: Data
/10
Population: 2,942
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 2,354
Property Crime Per 100k: 3,891
Median Home Value: $61,480 (14th worst)
Median Income: $29,420 (13th worst)
More on Mlk Park: Data
/10
Population: 2,465
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 2,188
Property Crime Per 100k: 3,789
Median Home Value: $65,150 (15th worst)
Median Income: $24,229 (3rd worst)
More on Masten Park: Data
/10
Population: 685
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 479
Property Crime Per 100k: 1,940
Median Home Value: $44,050 (4th worst)
Median Income: $27,932 (7th worst)
More on Valley: Data
/10
Population: 5,495
Violent Crimes Per 100k: 2,529
Property Crime Per 100k: 3,325
Median Home Value: $58,000 (12th worst)
Median Income: $34,202 (19th worst)
More on Grider: Data
Methodology: How we determined the most dangerous Buffalo neighborhoods in 2024
To figure out how bad a place is to live in, we only needed to know what kinds of things people like and then decide what places have the least amount of those things. We plugged the following criteria into Saturday Night Science to get the worst neighborhoods in Buffalo:
- High crime (Estimated)
- High unemployment (Less jobs)
- Low median income (Less pay)
- Low population density (No things to do)
- Low home values (No one’s willing to pay to live here)
Then, we ranked each neighborhood in Buffalo, New York for each of these criteria from worst to best.
Next, we averaged the individual rankings for each criterion into a “Worst Score.”
The neighborhood with the lowest “Worst Score” ranks as the most dangerous neighborhood of Buffalo.
The article is an opinion based on facts and is meant as infotainment. We updated this article for 2024. This report is our time ranking the worst neighborhoods to live in Buffalo.
Skip to the end to see the list of all 50 neighborhoods ranked from worst to best.
Summary: The Worst Neighborhoods Around Buffalo
Well, there you have it — the worst of the neighborhoods in Buffalo with Emerson landing at the bottom of the pack.
The worst neighborhoods in Buffalo are Emerson, Broadway-Fillmore, Babcock, Squaw Island, Medical Park, Genesee Moselle, Mlk Park, Masten Park, Valley, and Grider.
As mentioned earlier, the neighborhoods in Buffalo aren’t all bad. South Abbott takes the cake as the best place to live in Buffalo.
The best neighborhoods in Buffalo are South Abbott, North Park, Starin Central, Albright, and Hamlin Park.
We ranked the neighborhoods from worst to best in the chart below.
For more New York reading, check out:
- Richest Cities In New York
- Safest Places In New York According To Science
- Worst Places To Live In New York State
Most Dangerous Neighborhoods To Live In Buffalo For 2024?
| Rank | Neighborhood | Population | Home Value | Median Income |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Emerson | 2,108 | $50,600 | $23,804 |
| 2 | Broadway-Fillmore | 8,749 | $39,727 | $23,868 |
| 3 | Babcock | 3,029 | $47,550 | $24,532 |
| 4 | Squaw Island | 462 | $75,600 | $28,346 |
| 5 | Medical Park | 2,102 | $31,100 | $32,992 |
| 6 | Genesee Moselle | 3,764 | $40,050 | $27,957 |
| 7 | Mlk Park | 2,942 | $61,480 | $29,420 |
| 8 | Masten Park | 2,465 | $65,150 | $24,229 |
| 9 | Valley | 685 | $44,050 | $27,932 |
| 10 | Grider | 5,495 | $58,000 | $34,202 |
| 11 | Schiller Park | 10,298 | $51,136 | $28,852 |
| 12 | Lovejoy | 6,127 | $57,822 | $32,108 |
| 13 | South Ellicott | 2,376 | $73,900 | $33,740 |
| 14 | Kingsley | 2,652 | $55,525 | $33,976 |
| 15 | Military | 4,024 | $98,467 | $37,590 |
| 16 | First Ward | 1,201 | $51,100 | $28,750 |
| 17 | Willert Park | 4,582 | $167,825 | $25,014 |
| 18 | Tifft | 1,045 | $57,600 | $38,752 |
| 19 | Kenfield | 7,136 | $58,729 | $36,236 |
| 20 | Emslie | 1,521 | $74,175 | $32,854 |
| 21 | Leroy | 5,169 | $110,557 | $36,770 |
| 22 | North Delaware | 2,232 | $158,943 | $44,597 |
| 23 | Lasalle | 9,088 | $91,614 | $42,032 |
| 24 | Black Rock | 6,883 | $127,562 | $40,531 |
| 25 | Kaisertown | 5,454 | $73,667 | $44,263 |
| 26 | Waterfront | 951 | $492,400 | $35,846 |
| 27 | Delaware Park | 1,741 | $227,840 | $63,047 |
| 28 | Triangle | 3,806 | $85,160 | $50,160 |
| 29 | Allen | 3,045 | $257,525 | $41,923 |
| 30 | Seneca | 2,907 | $84,680 | $39,029 |
| 31 | Lakeview | 4,139 | $195,367 | $26,270 |
| 32 | Riverside Park | 11,251 | $71,100 | $28,679 |
| 33 | Kensington | 11,649 | $74,338 | $44,136 |
| 34 | Grant Ferry | 7,396 | $167,853 | $58,566 |
| 35 | Park Meadow | 3,361 | $268,100 | $72,990 |
| 36 | Columbus | 2,350 | $271,300 | $34,538 |
| 37 | Cazenovia Park | 5,098 | $93,060 | $40,789 |
| 38 | Bryant | 6,083 | $328,200 | $41,622 |
| 39 | South Park | 5,836 | $116,900 | $61,144 |
| 40 | University | 5,334 | $120,567 | $56,623 |
| 41 | Abbott Mckinley | 7,076 | $118,271 | $68,309 |
| 42 | Front Park | 12,235 | $197,789 | $41,665 |
| 43 | Forest | 9,331 | $231,118 | $61,585 |
| 44 | Parkside | 2,865 | $250,233 | $76,898 |
| 45 | Delaware-West Ferry | 6,397 | $325,714 | $60,893 |
| 46 | Hamlin Park | 6,045 | $103,980 | $46,968 |
| 47 | Albright | 2,729 | $412,040 | $68,808 |
| 48 | Starin Central | 5,145 | $232,700 | $74,251 |
| 49 | North Park | 12,100 | $225,476 | $71,004 |
| 50 | South Abbott | 3,476 | $122,600 | $80,316 |
This is a ridiculous article and very biased. Not sure what you hoped to accomplish with it.
I wouldn’t think much of this list. It lacks the real issues like violent crime. It also says 600 people live on Squaw Island.
#9 is krettner street not emslie
You’re “Detailed List” is lacking alot of details.
NO details…although I’ll go along w some of these rankings.
I grew up in babcock and I can tell you it isn’t glamorous but it certainly isn’t worse than the East side or west side! No one could pay me or all my bills and rent for me to live in ether of those areas! You hear about shootings all the time in those areas! The person who wrote this is shot!
i find this a bit off because I reside in the valley have my entire life and with all that’s happening at Larkin, canalside, riverworks, riverfest, and new businesses along seneca street, plus lofts being built, new dinners, ppl improving their houses how do you rate this. Anywho ty cause my taxes will stay low as my neighborhood thrives. Dam stereotypes with your own personal opinion
Agree !!!
This is so wrong!!
I have lived in Seneca-Babcock my entire life-56 1/2 years, and will tell you, it’s one of the closest-knitted nieghborhoods in the city of Buffalo. It’s true that we lack alot, that most nieghborhoods have, but we are on a rebound. The people are the best.
This article is very concerning for many reasons, but the poor language choices and lack of understanding of Buffalo’s clearly shown historical redlining of the city are the biggest offenders.
I’m sorry but, some of the comments are comments are true sad to say but, very much the truth indeed.
Babcock has it’s problem tell me one that doesn’t. I have a lot of great memories from the many years I spent there. And I have lived all over the world
Try living there before you talk
I’m curious as to how Squaw/unity Island managed to make this list considering that theres not one house in the entire island. How exactly did all your “science” manage to not tell you the island is a park?
The Lower West Side wasn’t even mentioned in this article and that’s where MOST of the Heroin is ! Philadelphia St. , 14th St., 15th St., Normal Ave. ( Irony ! ) it’s all hell.
AND the “Fruit Belt” / Lower Main St. wasn’t even mentioned either. Good God. Talk about derelicts. The East Side ( Fillmore / Bailey ) is only worse.